paper draft HIN-18-018 CWR comments by David Walter Type B: ________ Abstract: l2: "... is sensitive to the charge" color charge or electric charge? l8: proposed -> performed l11/12: "... comparing PbPb and pp data as a function of collision centrality." compared is pp data with PbPb data in different collision centrality regions _____________ 5. Jet charge measurement l146: If I remember correctly, ak4 jets have no fixed cone size, to be precise I would drop the "... that are located within the jet cone ..." and write something like: "... that have a relative angular distance from the jet axis of \Delta r =..." ___________ 7. Template fitting l199: "... added in quadrature ..." treated as uncorrelated ? l028: "... PbPb data than PYTHIA ... " -> "... PbPb data than it is modeled in PYTHIA ..."? ___________ 8. Systematic uncertainties l222: "added in quadrature" -> treated as uncorrelated ? Type A: l24: width -> variance l25: "... on both[,] jet energy and [jet] size[,] can ..." l97: "... requiring a jet to be present in an event[,] biases the data sample ..." l153: "... to both[,] hard and soft ..." l224: "The difference in [the] tracking ..." "... positive and negative [charged] particles ..." l233: "... positive and negative [charged] ..." l293: unprecise: " to be relatively flat " -> better, something like: "with no significant deviation from one"