Institutional review: Reading of TRG-17-001

Europe/Berlin
CMS Remote Centre (DESY)

CMS Remote Centre

DESY

Description

Modification PW: CWR

Link to cadi: http://cms.cern.ch/iCMS/analysisadmin/cadi?ancode=TRG-17-001

Link to CDS: http://cms.cern.ch/cds/TRG-17-001

=================================================
Guidelines for the Institutional Comments:

Spirit and intent of the Collaboration-Wide Review:
---------------------------------------------------
As a general guideline, we ask that individuals and groups reviewing a CMS publication draft concentrate on substantive matters of science and questions of clarity.
For the sake of streamlining the process, comments to a CMS publication draft are divided in two sets:
A. English/Style/Formatting (including figures)
B. Everything else (e.g. strategy, paper structure, emphasis, additions/subtractions, etc).
Comments of type B are the responsibility of the authors, who have to furnish clear answers to all such comments on CDS before the Final Reading can be scheduled.
Comments of type A are sent to the Language Editor responsible for [assigned to?] this paper,  (S)he will decide on any actions arising from such comments.
In general, responses to type A comments will not be posted on CDS, except in cases where an issue of language or style significantly affects the publication in question.

How to post comments during the CWR:
------------------------------------
The review should be posted as a 'comment' to the paper, indicating clearly that this was a CMS Institutional Review, along with the name of your institution.
All comments received from the reviewing institutions are answered by the authors and ARC on CDS.
To post a comment, you visit the paper link (http://cms.cern.ch/cds/TRG-17-001) and click on 'Detailed Record'.  This gives you access to the full paper and one of the links at the bottom says 'Submit a comment'.

 

Antonio
Comments Adinda
Comments by Rainer
DESY comments
Paul
Roberval (incomplete)
Slides
The agenda of this meeting is empty